Last night I went and saw the new HD Star Trek TOS episode(s) *The Menagerie* at the movie theater (with
kingwyatt and a newish co-worker).
OMG.
I went in an entire skeptic. I'd seen one episode of TOS on tv, with new special effects, and thought it was a big waste of time. I'm generally a believer in keeping the art the way it was originally created. But but but... the Okutas (long time Trek participants) went back to original source materials, film to scores, and recreated everything as originally done, but to contemporary standards. It was beautiful. They had a clip of Robert Justman saying this was the way the show should've gone out the door. That'll make a believer of anyone.
I utterly loved the music; the same sound, but in that nice big stereo plus room filling sound. There was a clip of the orchestra working which nearly brought a tear to me eye. To be in that band! ...The effects (ships, weapons) were beautiful.
One amusing side effect of the HD was noticing many minor flaws (particularly costume flaws; the Nearly Invisible Zipper was yet more visible; places where an insignia wasn't quite tacked down properly), which were invisible as originally done. I think this qualifies as the place where a tiny bit was lost; those flaws weren't flaws before.
They upped the contrast in the new version. Which is generally good, but overall did make a lot of scenes feel a bit darker. Still, the visual quality overall just sparkles.
Guess I'm gonna have to start saving my pennies for this too!